The Fourth Circuit leaves Maryland's Kalshi injunction denial in place.
Judge Gregory assumes the swap question and still finds no clear preemption. Judge Thacker would hold the contracts are not swaps. Judge Benjamin dissents.
- The appeal
- No. 25-1892, KalshiEX LLC v. Martin. Published. Argued 7 May 2026. Decided 18 November 2026. Judges Gregory, Thacker and DeAndrea Gist Benjamin. Per curiam affirmance, joined by Gregory and Thacker. Benjamin dissents.
- The court below
- District of Maryland at Baltimore, No. 1:25-cv-01283-ABA, Judge Adam B. Abelson. The slip says he denied a preliminary injunction on 1 August 2025, reported as KalshiEX LLC v. Martin, 793 F. Supp. 3d 667 (D. Md. 2025).
- The holding
- The judgment affirmed is that denial. The per curiam line does not decide whether the sports contracts are swaps. Gregory reserves that question. Thacker would hold they are not. Benjamin would hold they are, and that Maryland is field-preempted.
- The letter
- As Judge Gregory recounts it, a Maryland cease-and-desist of 7 April 2025 gave Kalshi fifteen days to stop offering the contracts in the state without a sports-wagering licence. Kalshi sued on 21 April 2025. This desk has not opened the letter.
The Fourth Circuit has left standing a district judge’s refusal to block Maryland from treating Kalshi’s sports contracts as sports wagering. The published slip opinion is dated 18 November. Chavdar Vasilev reported the result the same day for Gambling Insider, inside a wire that also covered other disputes. This note is the Maryland appeal only. This desk opened the slip opinion. It has not opened the district opinion, the 2025 cease-and-desist letter, or the argument recording.
The appeal is No. 25-1892, KalshiEX LLC v. Martin, from the District of Maryland at Baltimore, No. 1:25-cv-01283-ABA, before Judge Adam B. Abelson. Argument was on 7 May 2026. The panel is Judge Gregory, Judge Thacker and Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin. The opinion of the court is one sentence. The judgment below is affirmed. Judge Gregory and Judge Thacker joined that sentence, and each filed a concurrence. Judge Benjamin dissented. William E. Havemann of Milbank argued for Kalshi. Neal Kumar Katyal is on the brief. Max F. Brauer argued for the state. The caption names Attorney General Anthony G. Brown, John A. Martin as secretary of the lottery commission and director of the lottery agency, the agency, the commission, and eight other officials, each in an official capacity.
The order that survives is a refusal. Judge Gregory writes that on 1 August 2025 the district court denied Kalshi’s motion for a preliminary injunction, in an opinion he cites as KalshiEX LLC v. Martin, 793 F. Supp. 3d 667 (D. Md. 2025). He writes that Judge Abelson assumed, without deciding, that the sports event contracts were swaps, and still found no likelihood of success. The line he quotes is that Congress had not clearly and manifestly intended to strip states of their authority to regulate gambling. He writes that the district court stopped there, and did not reach irreparable harm, the balance of equities, or the public interest. The affirmance keeps that denial. The slip does not itself direct Kalshi to pull the contracts out of Maryland.
Judge Gregory places the suit after a letter. He writes that on 7 April 2025 the Maryland gaming authorities told Kalshi it was offering wagering on sporting events to people in the state without the sports-wagering licence in Md. Code Ann., State Gov’t § 9-1E-03, and that it had fifteen days to stop. He writes that the state reads the contracts as sports wagering under §§ 9-1E-01(j) and 9-1E-01(e). A licensee, in his account, would take on data-security duties and advertising limits, including bars on deceptive ads and on ads aimed at people who are not allowed to wager and at others the state treats as at risk. Kalshi filed on 21 April 2025 and moved the same day for an injunction. Those dates, and that account of the licence, are his. This desk has not opened the code.
His concurrence does not decide whether the contracts are swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act. He writes that the answer is unnecessary. Even if they are, he finds that 7 U.S.C. § 2(a)(1)(A), read with the special rule for gaming contracts at § 7a-2(c)(5)(C), does not clearly take sports-event trading on a designated contract market away from Maryland. He treats gambling as a traditional state police power and will not infer a displacement of it without a clear statement from Congress. He also finds no conflict that makes following both regimes impossible. A state licence, as he describes it, leaves Kalshi able to meet the Act. He writes that the firm has advertised itself as the first app for legal sports betting in all 50 states and as the first nationwide legal sports betting platform.
Judge Thacker concurs in the affirmance and would answer the swap question against Kalshi. She reads 7 U.S.C. § 1a(47)(A)(ii) to cover a payment that depends on whether an event occurs, or on the extent to which it occurs. A Kalshi sports contract, she writes, pays on the result of a contest the contract takes as given. She treats that result and the occurrence of the contest as different things, and she treats a dictionary sense of event as outcome as archaic. On her reading the contracts are not swaps, they sit outside the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s exclusive jurisdiction, and Maryland may regulate them alongside the Commission. She adds that the other reading would turn an ordinary sports bet, placed away from a designated market, into a federal crime under 7 U.S.C. § 2(e). She cites the Ninth Circuit’s opinion in KalshiEX, LLC v. Assad, 2026 WL 2543846 (9th Cir. Aug. 28, 2026), for the same view of the swap definition. This paper filed that opinion, and the later refusal to rehear it, on 5 November.
Judge Benjamin dissents. She would hold that the sports-related contracts are swaps, that the Act occupies the field of trading on a designated contract market, and that Kalshi has shown a likelihood of success. She would vacate the denial and return the remaining injunction factors to the district court. She does not accept a line between a contest and its result. She would still put parlays and proposition bets outside the swap definition, because she does not see a reasonable hedge in them, or an economic consequence apart from the wager. She cites KalshiEX LLC v. Flaherty, 172 F.4th 220 (3d Cir. 2026), for exclusive federal jurisdiction once a contract is a swap. Judge Gregory’s concurrence says the courts of appeals have not agreed. The parentheticals he prints give Flaherty a preemption holding, and give no-preemption holdings to Kalshiex LLC v. Schuler, 2026 WL 1295806 (6th Cir. Apr. 24, 2026), and to KalshiEx LLC v. Assad, 190 F.4th 1098 (9th Cir. 2026). Judge Benjamin cites a later Sixth Circuit writing in Schuler, 2026 WL 2884087 (Sept. 25, 2026), against her own preemption view. This desk has not reopened those opinions for this note.
The caption lists Paradigm Operations LP and Underdog Sports Holding, Inc. as amici for Kalshi. On the state’s side it lists Nevada, Ohio, 36 other states and the District of Columbia, the American Gaming Association, and a group of tribal parties. This desk has not opened the briefs.