The Ninth Circuit denies Kalshi another hearing in Nevada.
No judge asked for a vote of the full court. Election contracts go back to the district judge. The order is silent on the Supreme Court.
- The order
- No. 25-7516, KalshiEX, LLC v. Assad. Entered 4 November 2026 at 8:57 a.m. Judges Ryan D. Nelson, Bridget S. Bade and Kenneth K. Lee. Panel rehearing and rehearing en banc denied. No judge requested a vote. Fed. R. App. P. 40.
- What stands
- Opinion of 28 August 2026, argued 16 April in San Francisco. The dissolution of the preliminary injunction is affirmed as to sports-related event contracts. Election contracts are remanded to Judge Andrew P. Gordon, D. Nev. No. 2:25-cv-00575.
- The petition
- Filed 9 September 2026, 78 pages. Counsel of record Neal Kumar Katyal of Milbank. It asks for rehearing on a split with the Third Circuit in KalshiEX LLC v. Flaherty.
- The clock
- The order does not mention the Supreme Court. Under Supreme Court Rule 13, a certiorari petition is due 90 days after denial of a timely rehearing petition. Counted from 4 November, that date is 2 February 2027.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has refused to rehear Kalshi’s loss against Nevada gaming regulators. CDC Gaming reported the denial on 4 November. This desk opened the docket, the 28 August opinion, the 9 September petition, and the two letters about whether the court should wait for a new federal rule. A separate PDF of the 4 November order is not in the free archive. The docket entry, stamped 8:57 a.m. that morning, is the text this note uses.
The appeal is No. 25-7516, KalshiEX, LLC v. Assad, from the District of Nevada, No. 2:25-cv-00575, before Judge Andrew P. Gordon. Judges Ryan D. Nelson, Bridget S. Bade and Kenneth K. Lee were the panel. The entry says they unanimously vote to deny the petition for rehearing and the petition for rehearing en banc, that the full court has been told of the en banc request, and that no judge has asked for a vote on whether to rehear the case. It cites Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 40. Both petitions are denied. A clerk’s note on the September filing, edited the morning of the order, says the petition was captioned only for this appeal and that the denial required no action in the companion appeals, Nos. 25-7187 and 25-7831.
The opinion the panel left in place was filed on 28 August, after argument in San Francisco on 16 April. Judge Nelson wrote it. Judge Lee concurred. The panel affirmed, in part, the order dissolving a preliminary injunction. That injunction had stopped the Nevada Gaming Control Board, the Nevada Gaming Commission, and their members, sued in their official capacities, from enforcing state law against Kalshi’s sports-related event contracts. The court held that those contracts are likely not swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act. The Commission’s exclusive jurisdiction runs to swaps traded on a designated contract market. A reading wide enough to treat the result of a game as that kind of event, the panel said, has no stopping point, and it would treat Congress as having tucked a national sports-betting regime into the definition of a swap. The district court did not abuse its discretion on the equities. Election contracts are a different piece. The opinion says Judge Gordon had not decided whether they are swaps, describes them as illegal under Nevada law, and calls them a fraction of the business. That question goes back to him.
The opinion records how the fight started. Kalshi is a designated contract market. In January 2025 it self-certified sports-event contracts and began listing them, including who wins the Super Bowl, a draft pick, a halftime song, props and parlays. The court says the firm advertises itself as the first app for legal sports betting in all 50 states, and that in 2025 more than 90 percent of its trades, accounting for 95 percent of revenue, were sports-related. In March 2025 the Board sent a cease-and-desist letter. As the opinion describes that letter, the Board called the sports contracts a system of wagering, said Kalshi was running an unlicensed sports pool under Nevada Revised Statutes sections 463.160(1) and 463.245(2), and warned of civil or criminal enforcement if the contracts stayed on offer in the state. Judge Gordon granted an injunction in April 2025 and later dissolved it, using the reasoning from his refusal of a similar injunction to Crypto.com.
Kalshi’s petition, filed on 9 September and running 78 pages, asks for another hearing because of a split with the Third Circuit. Counsel of record is Neal Kumar Katyal of Milbank. The petition says the panel accepted exclusive federal jurisdiction over swaps and then held that sports-event contracts likely fall outside that word, leaving the firm open to civil and criminal liability while it follows the Commission. It points to KalshiEX LLC v. Flaherty, 172 F.4th 220 (3d Cir. 2026), where that court treated the contracts as swaps. This paper reported on 23 October that New Jersey has asked the Supreme Court to take the Third Circuit case, with Kalshi’s response due on 9 November.
On 25 September Kalshi wrote to the clerk that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission expected a revised version of 17 C.F.R. § 40.11 within two months, and asked the court to rehear the case en banc or to hold the petition until that rule appeared. On 1 October Nicole A. Saharsky answered for the Nevada appellees. She wrote that a revision would leave the holding on swaps where it is, and she called the request another attempt at delay. Judge Lee’s concurrence, filed with the August opinion, says the rule now on the books still bars gaming contracts and controls this appeal, even though a revision has been proposed. The 4 November order does not discuss the rule or the Third Circuit.
The order is also silent on the Supreme Court. Under that Court’s Rule 13, the time to petition for a writ of certiorari runs from the denial of a timely rehearing petition, and the period is 90 days. Counted from 4 November, the date is 2 February 2027. Whether the Court takes the case is a separate decision. The August ruling reviews a preliminary injunction. It is not a final judgment on every claim in the lawsuit.