Trade paper

Markets Texas Capital puts Sands China's 2028 Macau earnings just under US$2.28 billion.

Legal

Robinhood and Polymarket sued Missouri the day the state countersued Novig.

Robinhood brings a single preemption count and asks for a temporary order. Polymarket adds the Commerce Clause and a fee request. The attorney general's counterclaims use a federal payments statute, the state consumer law and public nuisance.

bookmaker.solutions

Two complaints
9 November 2026. Robinhood Derivatives, LLC v. Hanaway, Eastern District of Missouri, No. 4:26-cv-01932, 35 pages. QCX LLC, doing business as Polymarket US, v. Hanaway, No. 4:26-cv-01930, 40 pages. The Polymarket caption also prints 26-cv-1930.
The answer
The same day, Ludlow Exchange, LLC, doing business as Novig, v. Hanaway, No. 4:26-cv-01780, Document 23, an 83-page answer and counterclaims. The counterclaims are the attorney general's.
The companies
Declarations and injunctions against applying Missouri gambling and sports-wagering law to their event contracts. Robinhood also asks for a temporary restraining order. Polymarket also asks for fees.
The state
Dismissal of Novig's complaint. An injunction against taking financial instruments from Missouri residents for internet gambling the state calls unlawful. Restitution, civil penalties of up to $1,000 a violation, and a finding that the operation is a public nuisance.
Unopened
The September letters, Missouri Gaming Commission Resolution No. 25-139, and the earlier complaints Robinhood lists. No order on the 9 November filings is in the papers this desk opened.

Gambling Insider’s 10 November wire led with a set of Missouri papers filed the day before. This desk opened the three of them. Two are new complaints in the Eastern District of Missouri. The third is the state’s answer in a case already on that docket. All three are pleadings.

Robinhood Derivatives, LLC filed No. 4:26-cv-01932 on 9 November. The complaint runs 35 pages. It names Attorney General Catherine L. Hanaway, Michael A. Leara as executive director of the Missouri Gaming Commission, Jan M. Zimmerman as chairman, and commissioners Kevin M. Spaulding, Kevin Cantwell, Sam Gladney and Roger Stottlemyre, each in an official capacity. The single count is preemption under the Supremacy Clause. The prayer asks for a temporary restraining order, a preliminary injunction and a permanent injunction against enforcement of the state’s gambling and sports-wagering provisions, including Article III, Section 39(g) of the Missouri Constitution, and for a declaration that using those laws on the company’s event-contract business violates the Supremacy Clause. Counsel are Husch Blackwell in St. Louis and Cravath, Swaine & Moore. The Cravath lawyers’ admissions are marked as still to be sought.

The complaint describes the plaintiff as a futures commission merchant registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. It says the contracts trade on designated contract markets and that Robinhood facilitates orders. The markets it names are KalshiEx, LLC, ForecastEx LLC, Rothera Exchange and Clearing LLC, and North American Derivatives Exchange, Inc., which it calls Nadex. It says sports contracts are among those offered through Kalshi, that sports contracts through ForecastEx ran for a limited period beginning in 2025 and are not offered that way now, that Rothera has been a route since June 2026, and that certain sports contracts have moved through Nadex since September 2026. It describes Rothera as a joint venture of the parent, Robinhood Markets, Inc., and another entity, and Nadex as owned by the same parent as the Crypto.com and OG.com platforms. It says Robinhood has offered event contracts to customers in Missouri for more than a year.

On the state’s demand, the complaint describes a letter of 16 September 2026, signed by Solicitor General Louis J. Capozzi III and captioned “Unlicensed Sport Wagering Operations in Missouri,” sent from the attorney general’s office at 815 Olive Street in St. Louis. As the complaint gives that letter, it told Robinhood to stop offering sports wagering in the state or to obtain a commission licence, pay the taxes and fees, and stop offering sports wagering to people under 21. It says the letter allowed 30 days and warned that the state would take legal action. It then quotes a message it dates 6 November 2026, in which the solicitor general said the attorney general “now intends to seek a judicial order compelling compliance with state law in at least three days.” The complaint says Robinhood wrote back on 16 October that it is a registered futures commission merchant, that the trades are anonymous and priced by the market, and that the licensing, tax and age rules are preempted. This desk has not opened either letter.

The complaint cites administrative fines of up to $50,000 a violation, or $100,000 where the violations arise from the same occurrence, pointing to Article III, Section 39(g)(4)(k) and the commission rule it prints as 11 C.S.R. § 45-20.150(4) and (5). It says the September letter cited a 10 percent wagering tax and licence fees of up to $500,000. On the licence, it says Robinhood is not an excursion gambling boat or a professional sports team and does not operate for either, and that the two direct mobile sports-wagering licences have already gone to DraftKings and Circa Sports. Those two names are the complaint’s.

Paragraph 63 lists four earlier challenges to the same threatened enforcement. KalshiEX LLC v. Hanaway, No. 4:26-cv-01860, filed in the Eastern District on 27 October 2026. Ludlow Exchange, LLC v. Hanaway, No. 4:26-cv-01780, filed in the Eastern District on 16 October 2026. North American Derivatives Exchange, Inc. v. Hanaway, No. 4:26-cv-00969, filed in the Western District on 16 October 2026. Underdog Exchange DCM, Inc. v. Hanaway, No. 2:26-cv-04300, filed in the Western District on 8 November 2026. This desk opened the 9 November answer in the Ludlow case. It has not opened the other three complaints.

QCX LLC, doing business as Polymarket US, filed on the same day. The electronic header reads No. 4:26-cv-01930. The caption prints 26-cv-1930. The complaint runs 40 pages. The defendants are Hanaway, Zimmerman as chairman, and the same four commissioners. Count I is preemption by the Commodity Exchange Act, brought under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and Ex parte Young. Count II is a Commerce Clause claim, also under section 1983. The prayer asks for a declaration that the sports-wagering and gaming laws, including Article III, Section 39(g), are preempted and unconstitutional as applied to Polymarket US, for preliminary and permanent injunctions, and for fees and costs, including under 42 U.S.C. § 1988. Local counsel is Dowd Bennett in St. Louis. Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher appears on admissions still to be sought. The complaint says Polymarket US operates a designated contract market under the commission’s exclusive jurisdiction.

Its account of the 16 September letter is a 30-day choice: stop “offering sports wagering to individuals located in the State of Missouri,” or obtain a commission licence, pay the taxes and fees, and stop offering sports wagering to people in the state under 21. It says talks after the letter failed. On who may hold a licence, it says the constitution and the rules limit online sports wagering to an owner of an excursion gambling boat in the state, or an operator for that owner, to a professional sports team located in the state or that team’s operator, or to one of not more than two direct licensees chosen in a competitive process. It says both direct licences have been awarded, citing Missouri Gaming Commission Resolution No. 25-139 of 15 August 2025, so the remaining route is affiliation with a gambling boat or a sports team in Missouri. It attacks a rule it cites as 11 CSR 45-20.290(5), which it says requires a licensee’s servers to sit physically in Missouri, and the geofencing rule that limits a licensee to bettors physically in the state. This desk has not opened the resolution or the letter.

The same day’s answer is Document 23 in No. 4:26-cv-01780, 83 pages, file-stamped 9 November. The caption prints the executive director as Michael A. Lear. The Robinhood caption prints Michael A. Leara. The case caption on the answer includes a jury demand. Hanaway, Lear and Zimmerman answer together. The counterclaims are pleaded by Hanaway alone. Capozzi signs as solicitor general, with William James Seidleck, Graham Miller and Aadir Aktar Ibrahim Khan of that office. The signature block gives the Old Post Office Building, 815 Olive Street, Suite 200, St. Louis, and a certificate says the paper was served through the court’s electronic system on 9 November.

The counterclaims allege that Novig offers and settles stakes on professional and collegiate sports for people located in Missouri, that the commission has not licensed it, and that it takes money, credit, electronic fund transfers and other financial instruments from those people. They describe a binary contract, a yes or a no on a defined sporting result, with payment to the side that is right and nothing to the other. They say the state loses tax from licensed sports wagering, in an amount they do not quantify, and that an unlicensed operator misses the licence conditions on minors and on false or misleading promotion. Novig’s complaint, as the numbered paragraphs in the answer reprint it, alleges that the futures commission designated Ludlow Exchange as a contract market on 16 June 2026. The answer says the state lacks knowledge of that paragraph and denies it.

Counterclaim I uses the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act of 2006. The pleading says the Act does not itself outlaw a wager and instead takes the law of the place where the bet is initiated, received or made. It alleges that a sports wager with an unlicensed operator is unlawful under Article III, Section 39(g) and chapter 572, and is therefore unlawful internet gambling, and that accepting the instruments violates 31 U.S.C. § 5363. The prayer on that count asks for an order restraining Novig from accepting financial instruments from Missouri residents in connection with that gambling. Counterclaim II uses the Missouri Merchandising Practices Act, section 407.020. It calls the unlicensed offering an unfair practice and asks for an injunction, restitution to the state for distribution to injured people, civil penalties of up to $1,000 a violation under section 407.100.6, and the costs of investigation and prosecution. Counterclaim III calls the operation a public nuisance, on the ground that the dominating element is chance and that the play is open to the public without the required licence, and it asks for a declaration and an injunction. The prayer also asks the court to refuse Novig’s own request for declaratory and injunctive relief and to dismiss Novig’s complaint with prejudice.

The complaints state what the companies allege and what they want. The counterclaims state what the attorney general alleges and what she wants. This desk has not seen a reply from Novig, or an answer in the Robinhood or Polymarket cases. The Gambling Insider wire also carries other items from the same day, among them fresh suits in Arkansas, a tribal brief in a New York appeal, remarks by a Nevada senator, a Florida penalty proposal, a Wisconsin intervention, a preliminary quarter from Bally’s and a digital card product. Those sit outside this note. The Arkansas complaints against Kalshi and VGW are already filed here.

Sources

  1. Gambling Insider, 10 November 2026
  2. Complaint, Robinhood Derivatives, LLC v. Hanaway, No. 4:26-cv-01932
  3. Complaint, QCX LLC v. Hanaway, No. 4:26-cv-01930
  4. Answer and counterclaims, Ludlow Exchange, LLC v. Hanaway, No. 4:26-cv-01780, Document 23