Trade paper

Markets Texas Capital puts Sands China's 2028 Macau earnings just under US$2.28 billion.

Legal

Torch will pay Missouri $13.5 million, and the release says the machines are off.

The written release and the trade report describe different terms. This desk has not opened the agreement.

bookmaker.solutions

Catherine Hanaway, in a black coat and red top, speaking with men beside her in front of a wall of campaign posters.
Restyled from the CDC Gaming photograph.
The payment
Attorney general's release, 16 November 2026. $13.5 million in restitution. A further $6.5 million if Torch violates the agreement. The compliance payment goes to the Gaming Proceeds for Education Fund, then to school districts through the Classroom Trust Fund.
The machines
The same release says Torch devices in Missouri have been recalled, disabled, or taken out of public use in all businesses. Catherine Hanaway is quoted saying Torch Electronics will stop operating in the state.
The parties
Announced with Tom Albus, U.S. attorney for the Eastern District of Missouri, and R. Matthew Price, U.S. attorney for the Western District. No admission of liability by Torch or Steven Miltenberger. The agreement binds Torch and any successor and resolves the ongoing civil and criminal investigations.
The order
TNT Amusements, Inc. v. Torch Electronics, LLC, No. 4:23-cv-330-JAR (E.D. Mo.). Memorandum and order, Doc. 437, Judge John A. Ross, 13 February 2026. The devices are gambling devices under Mo. Rev. Stat. § 572.010 and illegal outside a licensed casino.
The gap
CDC Gaming reports a nonprofit exception, three payments of $4.5 million, and a breach sum of $0.65 million. The release this desk opened prints none of those terms. The agreement itself is not attached.

Chris Sieroty reported on 17 November that Torch Electronics had agreed to pay Missouri $13.5 million and to keep its machines out of for-profit businesses. The note he filed for CDC Gaming also says the company may keep the machines in veterans halls, fraternal clubs and other nonprofits. This desk opened the attorney general’s release of 16 November, the office’s release of 8 April, and the memorandum Judge John A. Ross signed on 13 February. It has not opened the agreement.

The 16 November release, from Jefferson City, says Attorney General Catherine Hanaway and the U.S. attorneys for the Eastern and Western Districts of Missouri have an agreement with Torch. It says the company’s devices in the state have been recalled, disabled, or taken out of public use in all businesses. In the lines the release prints, Hanaway says Torch will stop operating in Missouri and that the money recovered will support classrooms. The sum is $13.5 million in restitution, with a further $6.5 million if Torch violates the agreement. The release sends what it calls the compliance payment to the Gaming Proceeds for Education Fund, which pays eligible school districts through the Classroom Trust Fund.

Tom Albus, for the Eastern District, is quoted saying his office worked the case with the attorney general and with his counterpart in the Western District, and that the offices mean to keep a common line against illegal gambling. R. Matthew Price, for the Western District, is quoted saying federal law never left these machines in a gray area, and that the agreement rejects businesses that break that law and take the proceeds from Missouri communities. The release says the agreement ends the ongoing civil and criminal investigations into Torch, binds the company and any successor, and is not an admission of liability by Torch or by Steven Miltenberger. It thanks the Missouri State Highway Patrol and the Missouri Gaming Commission. It attaches no agreement, names no criminal case number, and sets no payment calendar.

On 8 April the same office said Torch, which it called the largest provider of illegal gambling devices in the state, had agreed to suspend every operation from Friday 10 April. Customers were told to stop the machines by that Friday. The April release said the office and the U.S. attorneys were still seeking a lasting resolution, and it said state law makes it illegal to give people access to unregulated machines for gambling. The November release is the later public account of an agreement. It does not say the April suspension is the paper being replaced.

The February order is a different case. TNT Amusements, Inc., which does business as Play-Mor Coin-Op, sued Torch Electronics, LLC and others in the Eastern District of Missouri, No. 4:23-cv-330-JAR. Ross’s memorandum and order is Doc. 437, dated 13 February 2026. The decretal line says the Torch devices the defendants market and distribute are gambling devices under Mo. Rev. Stat. § 572.010 and are therefore illegal under Missouri law when operated outside a licensed casino. That line points at Doc. 423. This desk opened Doc. 437. It has not opened Doc. 423.

The memorandum is a partial declaratory judgment on Count VII, after a jury found for TNT on false advertising and unfair competition. Trial of those counts started on 29 September 2025 and ran five days. To find liability, the jury had to treat as false or misleading at least one of four sales lines, among them a claim that chance has no role in any outcome and a claim that the device fits no Missouri definition of a gambling device and is not barred. Ross writes that the jury, after two hours, found falsity in one or more of the lines. He writes that experts for both sides showed multiple elements of chance, and that no theme on the devices has an element of skill.

On the mechanics, the memorandum says each device holds, for each theme, an ordered list of prize multipliers, in pools he puts at 60,000 to 100,000 entries. Banilla Games, in North Carolina, shuffles that list before the device is shipped. The first play of a theme at a given stake draws a starting point with a random-number generator, from twelve possible starts. From there the software walks a fixed sequence. The picture the player sees, usually symbols on a reel, is chosen afterward by another random draw that fits the prize already fixed. An optional prize viewer shows only the next prize, in dollars and cents. It does not show the symbols, and it does not show any prize after the next one. A player who wants a later result has to pay through the turns in front of it. The lowest bill the devices take is one dollar. They do not hand back a balance under that, so a player who stops at $1.75 is paid $1.00. Ross writes that the viewer is optional, that not every player uses it, and that using it does not change the chance of a better payout. He treats the feature as beside the point under a statute that reaches a device used or usable for gambling.

The same memorandum prints a 2019 letter from the general counsel of the Missouri Gaming Commission, after staff examined an NCG 2 device. As the order quotes it, the letter told the recipient that placing the devices at a VFW post would violate sections 572.030, 572.040 and 572.070, and that a choice to see a prize before the first play did not lift those bans. Ross stops at the state-law label. He does not declare that Torch runs an illegal gambling business under 18 U.S.C. § 1955, and he calls any further declaration redundant. The memorandum identifies Miltenberger as Torch’s president and majority owner.

CDC Gaming’s report of the 16 November announcement adds terms the release does not print. It says the company may go on operating in veterans halls, fraternal clubs and other nonprofit locations, and may sign new nonprofit locations until 1 January. It says Hanaway limited that path to nonprofits that already exist, and that a newly formed charity, or a taped-off corner of a convenience store, would fall outside the agreement. It sets the money as $4.5 million in the week of the report and $4.5 million in each of the next two years. Those three payments add to the $13.5 million the release states. That addition is this desk’s. It prints the extra sum for a breach as $0.65 million, a tenth of the $6.5 million in the release. Sieroty also has Hanaway saying officers are already looking at possible breaches, that the office will keep investigating other companies, and that she expects more settlements. Those lines are his account of what she said. They are not in the release. Until the agreement is public, the nonprofit exception and the instalments stay with the trade report.

Sources

  1. CDC Gaming, 17 November 2026
  2. Missouri Attorney General, 16 November 2026
  3. Missouri Attorney General, 8 April 2026
  4. Memorandum and order, TNT Amusements, Inc. v. Torch Electronics, LLC, No. 4:23-cv-330-JAR (E.D. Mo. 13 February 2026)