Nine senators ask Selig to withdraw the geofence reading.
The release gives markets thirty days to drop a domestic geographic limit or explain why they cannot. The senators say that clock runs through court orders still in force.
- The letter
- 16 November 2026, Washington. Nine signature blocks. The senators ask Chairman Michael S. Selig to withdraw the 5 November interpretation or freeze it until the cases end, and to answer in writing by 23 November 2026.
- The minimum
- If the text stays, the Commission must say that three geographic limits do not violate 17 CFR 38.151(b): one a court has ordered, one adopted to meet the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act or a tribal-state compact, and one an exchange adopts on its own.
- The hold
- Keep records and communications on the letter's topics from 1 January 2025 onward, including personal email, phones, and encrypted or disappearing messages, and suspend automatic deletion. Confirm that hold in the 23 November reply.
- The release
- Release 9323-26, 5 November 2026. Designated contract markets must stop domestic geographic restrictions that violate the impartial-access rule within 30 days, or tell the Division of Market Oversight why that is not feasible. Thirty days after 5 November falls on 5 December. That day is this desk's count.
- The register
- 91 FR 72407, effective 10 November 2026, issued in Washington on 5 November. Geographic access restrictions are called inconsistent with the Commodity Exchange Act and the Commission's rules. Chairman Selig voted yes. No commissioner voted no.
Nine senators have asked the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to take back a reading that treats a domestic geographic block on a designated contract market as a breach of impartial access. The letter is dated 16 November 2026. It is sent from the Senate in Washington to Chairman Michael S. Selig at Three Lafayette Centre, 1155 21st Street NW. Chris Sieroty carried it for CDC Gaming the same day. This desk opened the letter, release 9323-26, and the interpretation as printed in the Federal Register.
Seven names are printed clearly enough to read: Adam B. Schiff, Catherine Cortez Masto, Amy Klobuchar, Maria Cantwell, Alex Padilla, Elissa Slotkin and Gary C. Peters. Klobuchar signs as ranking member of the Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry. Two further signature blocks sit on the second and third pages. The typed names under them are covered in the file this desk opened. The handwriting on those blocks reads as Jacky Rosen and Patty Murray. CDC Gaming names the same pair, which completes the Nevada and Washington delegations beside Cortez Masto and Cantwell. Nine blocks is this desk’s count. Schiff’s office posted the PDF.
The first request is that the Commission withdraw the interpretation, or freeze every step taken to carry it out until the litigation is over. Short of withdrawal, the letter wants an express statement that three limits do not violate Commission Regulation 38.151(b). Those are a geographic restriction a court has imposed, one an exchange adopts so as to comply with the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act or a tribal-state compact, and one an exchange adopts on its own.
A preservation demand follows. The Commission is asked to keep every record and communication on the topics in the letter, from 1 January 2025 through the present, and to keep new material as it appears. The hold, as written, covers the Commission’s own files and the files of any person or entity representing it or claiming to act for it. The list runs through official and personal email, mobile devices, encrypted and disappearing-message applications, social media, calendar entries, meeting notes, voicemail and text messages. Where an automatic deletion tool is in use, the letter says that tool should be switched off at once, and that people who control similar records should be told they are under the same duty. The reply is requested by 23 November 2026, and it is to include a written confirmation that the hold is in place.
The document they are answering is release 9323-26, issued on 5 November. The release says designated contract markets must cease domestic geographic restrictions that violate the impartial-access requirements within 30 days, or else send the Division of Market Oversight a reason why that compliance is not feasible. A further sentence puts the same thirty days on intermediaries that reach those markets: the markets should see that those firms are not impeding the rule, or explain why that is not feasible. The Commission says it will look at the facts of a particular case before it acts. Thirty days after 5 November falls on 5 December. The release does not print that day. The count is this desk’s.
The interpretation itself appears in the Federal Register of 10 November, starting at 91 FR 72407, and the entry says it was issued in Washington on 5 November. Christopher Kirkpatrick signs as secretary of the Commission. A voting note says Chairman Selig voted in the affirmative and that no commissioner voted in the negative. The register takes effect on 10 November. The thirty-day instruction sits in the release. The register text says the Commission knows that some markets have limited access to certain event-contract markets according to where a prospective trader is, or where that trader lives. It says the statute and the rules generally do not allow a market to limit access, inside the United States, by the location of someone who otherwise qualifies. A limit that admits people from one state and bars them from another is described as excluding eligible people. The Commission’s conclusion, in its own words as paraphrased here, is that geographic access restrictions are inconsistent with the Commodity Exchange Act and with the Commission’s rules. The line that follows is an expectation that markets will review their access criteria, their exchange rules, and the arrangements by which intermediaries reach the market, and will bring those arrangements into line. A footnote says a market must take reasonable steps so that an intermediary does not impose a geographic restriction that breaks impartial access, and that the market is responsible for seeing that intermediaries are not standing in the way of the rule.
The register uses a sports contract to show the point. Where a contract draws interest from one region, the example given is whether a home side goes on in a playoff, and the text says closing that region could thin the contract’s liquidity. An election market is treated the same way. The entry says much of the volume, and much of what the market reveals, may come from people in the state where the vote is held, and that shutting those people out could cut both.
The senators describe the same papers as an order to end location-based limits, geofencing included, within 30 days. They write that the decision conflicts with court orders still in force, undercuts state and tribal law, and has to be reversed. On their account, the reading would push markets to offer products they call improperly regulated gambling in all fifty states, without regard to state and tribal gaming law or to what state and federal courts have decided. They say 17 CFR 38.151(b) gives no basis for that reading, and that the argument has already been put in active cases and turned down. They say the Sixth Circuit and the Ninth Circuit have held that states may still apply their gaming laws to prediction markets, and that the Ninth Circuit has held, at the preliminary-injunction stage, that a sports event contract on tribal land is unauthorised Class III gaming under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act. They say courts have ordered platforms to stop offering various prediction contracts in Michigan, Nevada and Washington, and on the land of two California tribes, and have required geofences. They say the Commission now appears to be encouraging markets to offer contracts those orders forbid, while the cases remain open.
They write that they are particularly troubled because the step came just hours after the latest order of the Northern District of California in Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi, which required Kalshi to geofence the plaintiff tribes’ land. This paper filed that order on 7 November. The order is dated 4 November. The interpretation is dated 5 November. The word “hours” is the senators’ measure of the gap. They say the sequence raises a concern that the Commission may be coordinating with platforms that are in court, and encouraging those platforms to break state and tribal gaming law. That concern is stated in the letter. The letter attaches no message that shows such coordination.
The letter’s footnotes point to a Sixth Circuit opinion, to a Ninth Circuit opinion dated 28 August 2026, and to the Ninth Circuit opinion of 16 September 2026 in the tribal appeal. This desk did not reopen the first two. The September opinion, and the 4 November district order, are the ones already filed here. CDC Gaming also reports remarks the chairman gave to CNBC about taking the dispute to the Supreme Court, and about criminal charges brought in Utah. The letter does not quote that interview. This desk did not open it.